When Process Improvements Make Things Worse

When we don’t understand the nuance and principles behind a concept, we can take a seemingly good idea and apply it everywhere, possibly turning it into a detriment.

Consider process improvements. We’ve put so much value on them that we often blindly assume all process improvements are good. We allow local process improvements (such as those in one department) to create global suboptimization, burdening the whole organization.

This isn’t a new problem. W. Edwards Deming emphasized the importance of optimizing the entire system rather than its individual parts. As the Deming Institute explains, improving the results of one department or process doesn’t necessarily improve the overall organization.

One example I’ve seen is the growing number of different apps teams are required to use. Individual departments put these apps in place as process improvements without considering the overall cost to the business.

Another example comes from Mike Orzen, writing for the Lean Enterprise Institute. He describes a document control department that improved its process, reducing work that previously took days to just minutes. The team celebrated its success, only to discover that it had shifted work and problems to other departments. What looked like a major improvement for one team had actually created more problems for others.

The goal of a process improvement should be to make the end product less expensive, faster, or better. Making one team’s work easier doesn’t necessarily accomplish that.

As organizations mature in how they approach process improvement, they need to take steps to ensure an improvement is actually an improvement for the organization as a whole.

Here are a few methods organizations have used to deal with this problem:

  • Give cross-functional improvements an owner.
  • Create a cross-functional review process when an improvement adds work to another department.
  • Track the process tax. Calculate the time or money saved, including any added work for others, and make sure there is an overall benefit. Review the results again later.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.*

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Discover more from Calm Critical Work

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading